GAS · ELECTRIC · TANKLESS

Whitestown Water Heater Repair

Water heater not heating, leaking, or making noise? We repair gas, electric and tankless water heaters for homes in Whitestown. Call or text 317-922-9043 or book online. We’ll find the cause and give you an upfront price before we start.

✓ Same-day service

✓ Upfront pricing

✓ Licensed & insured

★★★★★ 5-star rated

CALL 317-922-9043

BOOK ONLINE

Hot Water Pros plumber repairing a wall-mounted tankless water heater in a basement utility room

Gas water heater and furnace in a garage utility area

BEFORE YOU CALL

Quick checks before you call

Electric heater

Check the breaker. If it tripped, reset it once. If it trips again, leave it off and call us — that usually points to a shorted element or wiring.

Gas heater

Make sure the gas control isn’t set to Off or Vacation and that your other gas appliances work. Never relight a pilot if you smell gas.

Tankless heater

Write down the error code on the display. It helps us bring the right parts.

Leak

Close the cold-water valve and turn off the power or gas to the heater.

HOW IT WORKS

How a service visit works

Call or book

Call or text 317-922-9043, or book online.

We diagnose it

A licensed technician diagnoses the heater and shows you what failed.

You approve the price

You get an upfront price and approve it before we start. Common parts are on the truck, so many repairs are done the same visit.

What Type of Water Heater Needs Repair?

WHAT WE REPAIR

What we repair in Whitestown

Gas tank heaters

Pilot and ignition problems, thermocouples, gas controls, burners and venting.

Electric tank heaters

Heating elements, upper and lower thermostats, high-limit resets and wiring. Water heater keeps tripping the reset button?

Tankless heaters

Navien, Rinnai and other major brands — error codes, ignition, sensors, inlet filters and scale. See Navien tankless repair in Whitestown.

Every type

Leaks, relief valves, drain valves, anode rods and noisy tanks.

Sediment flushed from a tank water heater during a Hot Water Pros maintenance visit

Whitestown water and your water heater

Citizens Energy Group completed its purchase of Whitestown’s water utility and began serving Whitestown customers directly in late May 2026. Citizens’ 2025 water quality report lists average hardness of about 320 ppm, roughly 19 grains per gallon, and notes that hardness varies with the source water feeding each treatment plant.

That’s hard enough to build sediment in tank heaters and scale in tankless units over time, so regular flushing pays off. Can hard water damage a water heater?

Sources: Citizens Energy Group acquisition announcement · Citizens water quality reports

New Bradford White gas water heaters ready for installation

Repair or replace?

If the tank is sound and a part has failed, a repair is usually the smart move. If water is coming from the tank body, or an older heater needs a major part, replacement is often the better value. We’ll give you both options.

Qualifying new tank water heaters we install come with a 6-year manufacturer warranty. See Whitestown water heater replacement and our replacement prices.

Whitestown water heater repair FAQs

Do you have a Whitestown location?

No — our shop is in Fishers at 11 Municipal Drive, Suite 200. Our technicians come to homes throughout Whitestown. See all our water heater repair service areas.

Can you come out the same day?

Same-day service is available. Call or text early in the day for the best chance at a same-day visit, or book online and choose the first opening.

Why does my hot water run out so fast?

Common causes are sediment taking up space in the tank, a failed lower heating element on electric models, a broken dip tube, or a heater that’s too small for the household. Why am I running out of hot water so fast?

Why does my hot water smell like rotten eggs?

Usually a reaction between bacteria in the water and the tank’s anode rod. Replacing the anode rod and flushing the tank often fixes it. Hot water smells like rotten eggs