FISHERS · CARMEL · WESTFIELD · INDIANAPOLIS
Your Local Water Heater Replacement Experts
Same-day and next-day installs, backed by our 24-Hour Replacement Guarantee.
Your flat-rate price is set before any work begins. Serving Fishers, Carmel, Westfield, Noblesville, Zionsville, Whitestown and Indianapolis.
★★★★★ Real reviews from homeowners on Google
“Cameron and his crew came out and did a full replacement within a couple of hours!”
— Kevin S., Google review
FLAT-RATE PRICES
50-Gallon
Electric
$1,599
flat rate, installed
Est. $72.98/mo*
50-Gallon
Standard Gas
$1,849
flat rate, installed
Est. $84.39/mo*
Flat-rate prices for standard replacements: heater, installation, old-unit removal, and a shutoff valve, drain pan and expansion tank where applicable, with no added tax or fees.
*Est. payment: 24 months at 8.90% APR, $0 down, subject to credit approval. Your rate and payment may be different.
✓ 24-Hour Replacement Guarantee
✓ Same & Next-Day Installs
✓ 6-Year Manufacturer Warranty
✓ Licensed Indiana Plumbing Contractor
STANDARD TANK REPLACEMENTS
Choose Your Replacement
Most homes replace a 50-gallon electric or gas tank water heater. Need a different size or type? Every flat-rate price is listed right below.
50-Gallon Electric Water Heater Replacement
$1,599 installed
Est. $72.98/mo with financing*
✓ New 50-gallon electric water heater
✓ Delivery & standard installation
✓ Startup and testing
✓ Old-unit removal & disposal
✓ Shutoff valve, drain pan & expansion tank where applicable
✓ 6-year manufacturer warranty
50-Gallon Standard Gas Water Heater Replacement
$1,849 installed
Est. $84.39/mo with financing*
✓ New 50-gallon standard gas heater
✓ Delivery & standard installation
✓ Startup and testing
✓ Old-unit removal & disposal
✓ Shutoff valve, drain pan & expansion tank where applicable
✓ 6-year manufacturer warranty
Flat-rate installed prices for standard replacements. Work outside the standard scope is quoted and approved before we proceed. *Estimated payment based on 24 months at 8.90% APR, $0 down, subject to credit approval. Your rate and payment may be different.
Why Homeowners Choose Hot Water Pros
Water heater specialists
Water heater repair, replacement and tankless service is our core business.
Clear installed pricing
Flat-rate installed prices are published online, and any work outside the standard scope is quoted and approved first.
Licensed in Indiana
Indiana Plumbing Contractor license PC12500023.
6-year warranty
Tank water heaters we install carry a 6-year manufacturer warranty.
From Our Recent Jobs
Real photos of water heaters our team has installed and serviced around Central Indiana.
What Customers Say
★★★★★ Real reviews from homeowners on Google
“
When my 10-year-old water heater started to leak, they took the time to understand my needs and didn’t try to sell me on installing more than what my family and I need or will use.
— Andrew S., Google review
“
Cameron, Mitch and Tyler did an excellent job, were personable and professional, and respectful of me and my home.
— Pat P., Google review
“
They are extremely professional experts who show up same / next day and provide top quality services.
— Jen W., Google review
BEFORE & AFTER
WATER HEATER PROBLEM? NO PROBLEM!
Real photos from a water heater replacement we completed in Westfield, Indiana. The old tank was leaking, so we removed it and installed a new 50-gallon electric water heater in the same spot.
BEFORE
Leaking water heater
AFTER
New 50-gallon electric
24 Hour Replacement Guarantee
We get it done fast or your money back.
Financing Available
Flexible payment options for qualified customers.
Licensed & Insured
Fully licensed and insured
Highly Rated
5-star rating on Google.
What’s Included in Your Installed Price
Your flat-rate installed price covers a standard replacement. If your home needs work outside that scope, we quote it and get your approval before we proceed.
Included in your installed price
✓ New water heater
✓ Delivery
✓ Standard installation labor
✓ Startup and testing
✓ Removal and disposal of your old unit
✓ New shutoff valve, drain pan and expansion tank, where applicable
✓ 6-year manufacturer warranty on tank models
Outside the standard scope, quoted first
• Venting modifications
• Gas-line changes or electrical work
• Plumbing repairs or code corrections
• Difficult access
• Switching to a different size or type (priced above)
ALL FLAT-RATE PRICES
Flat-Rate Prices by Water Heater Size & Type
Flat-rate installed prices for standard replacements. Each price includes the water heater, standard installation labor, old-unit removal and disposal, and a new shutoff valve, drain pan and expansion tank where applicable, with no added tax or fees. Tank models carry a 6-year manufacturer warranty. Work outside the standard scope is quoted and approved before we proceed.
Electric Tank
50 gallon
$1,599 installed
Est. $72.98/mo*
Standard Gas Tank
50 gallon
$1,849 installed
Est. $84.39/mo*
75 gallon
$2,989 installed
Est. $136.41/mo*
Power-Vent Tank
50 gallon
$2,989 installed
Est. $136.41/mo*
75 gallon
$4,899 installed
Est. $223.58/mo*
Tankless
Tankless water heater
$4,499 installed
Est. $205.33/mo*
Not sure which type you have? Call or text 317-922-9043 and we’ll help you identify it.
*Est. payment: 24 months at 8.90% APR, $0 down, subject to credit approval. Your rate and payment may be different.
*All financing is subject to credit approval. Your terms may vary. Payment options through Wisetack are provided by our lending partners. For example, a $5,500 purchase could cost $253.54 per month for 24 months, based on a 9.9% APR, or $1,833.33 per month for 3 months, based on a 0% APR. Offers range from 0 to 35.9% APR based on amount requested and creditworthiness. Not all merchants and lending partners participate in 0% interest programs. Terms range from 3 - 120 months and may vary based on merchant, lending partner, or transaction size. State interest rate caps may apply. No prepaid finance charges or participation fees. See additional terms at wisetack.com/faqs.
HOW IT WORKS
Three Simple Steps to Hot Water
1
Call or request online
Call or text 317-922-9043, or request an installation online. Tell us about your current water heater.
2
Confirm your installation
We confirm the right replacement and your installed price, including any extra work, before anything begins.
3
Get hot water
We install, start up and test your new water heater, then remove and dispose of the old one.
2026 INDIANAPOLIS WATER HEATER PRICING GUIDE
Water Heater Replacement Cost in Indianapolis, IN
Hot Water Pros publishes flat-rate installed prices for electric, standard gas, power-vent and tankless water heater replacement in Indianapolis and nearby communities. Each price includes the water heater, standard installation labor, removal and disposal of your old unit, and a new shutoff valve, drain pan and expansion tank where applicable, with no added tax or fees.
Water Heater Replacement Cost FAQs
How much does water heater replacement cost in Indianapolis?
A standard 50-gallon electric water heater replacement is $1,599 installed, and a standard 50-gallon gas water heater replacement is $1,849 installed. Installed prices for 75-gallon, power-vent and tankless water heaters are listed in the price section above.
What is included in the installed price?
For a standard replacement, the installed price includes the new water heater, delivery, standard installation labor, startup and testing, removal and disposal of the old water heater, and a new shutoff valve, drain pan and expansion tank where applicable, with no added tax or fees. Tank models also carry a 6-year manufacturer warranty.
Will my price change after you arrive?
For a standard replacement, you pay one flat-rate installed price. If your home needs work outside the standard scope, such as venting modifications, gas-line or electrical changes, plumbing repairs, code corrections or difficult access, we quote that work and get your approval before we proceed.
How long does it take to replace a water heater?
Many standard residential water heater replacements can be completed during one appointment. Tankless conversions, difficult-access installations, and projects requiring substantial plumbing, gas, electrical, or venting upgrades may take longer.
Do you remove and dispose of my old water heater?
Yes. Removal and disposal of your old water heater is included in the installed price.
Does my new water heater come with a warranty?
Yes. Qualifying new tank water heaters we install come with a 6-year manufacturer warranty. Tankless water heaters we install come with a 15-year manufacturer’s limited warranty.
How do I get started?
Call or text 317-922-9043, or request an installation online. We confirm the right replacement and your installed price, including any extra work, before anything begins.
SERVICE AREAS
Proudly Serving Indianapolis and Surrounding Areas
Water heater replacement in Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, Noblesville, Westfield, Whitestown, Zionsville, Greenwood and Cicero.
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement