Cicero Water Heater
Replacement Experts
We replace water heaters in Cicero, around Morse Reservoir and across northern Hamilton County. Gas, electric, power-vent and tankless models are installed at one flat price that covers the heater, labor and haul-away. On a private well? We’ll factor in your water before recommending a model.
SAME-DAY
SERVICE
LICENSED & INSURED
UPFRONT PRICING
5 STAR RATED
Choose Your Water Heater Type
Fast Installation.
Reliable Hot Water.
WHY CICERO HOMEOWNERS
TRUST HOT WATER PROS
We proudly provide water heater replacement and installation services throughout Cicero, Hamilton County, and surrounding north Indianapolis communities.
24-Hour Hot Water Guarantee
We get it done fast, or your money back.
Licensed Installation
Every Cicero install is handled by licensed, bonded and insured plumbers.
6-Year Manufacturer Warranty
New water heaters are backed by a 6-year manufacturer warranty.
Financing Available
Flexible payment options for qualified customers.
Professional Units Provided
Professional-grade gas, electric and tankless units, supplied and installed by our team.
UPFRONT INSTALLED PRICING
Installed Price Includes Unit, Labor & Disposal. No Added Tax Or Fees
Also Includes A New Shutoff Valve, Drain Pan & Expansion Tank Where Applicable
50 Gallon Electric
$1,599 Installed
Estimated $72.98/mo* with financing
24 months · 8.90% APR · $0 down
50 Gallon Power Vent
$2,989 Installed
Estimated $136.41/mo* with financing
24 months · 8.90% APR · $0 down
50 Gallon Gas
$1,849 Installed
Estimated $84.39/mo* with financing
24 months · 8.90% APR · $0 down
75 Gallon Power Vent
$4,899 Installed
Estimated $223.58/mo* with financing
24 months · 8.90% APR · $0 down
75 Gallon Gas
$2,989 Installed
Estimated $136.41/mo* with financing
24 months · 8.90% APR · $0 down
Tankless Water Heater
$4,499 Installed
Estimated $205.33/mo* with financing
24 months · 8.90% APR · $0 down
*All financing is subject to credit approval. Your terms may vary. Payment options through Wisetack are provided by our lending partners. For example, a $5,500 purchase could cost $253.54 per month for 24 months, based on a 9.9% APR, or $1,833.33 per month for 3 months, based on a 0% APR. Offers range from 0 to 35.9% APR based on amount requested and creditworthiness. Not all merchants and lending partners participate in 0% interest programs. Terms range from 3 - 120 months and may vary based on merchant, lending partner, or transaction size. State interest rate caps may apply. No prepaid finance charges or participation fees. See additional terms at wisetack.com/faqs.
Cicero water and your new water heater
Hard water is the norm across central Indiana. Citizens Energy Group’s 2025 report puts typical regional hardness at about 200 to 425 ppm, or 12 to 25 grains per gallon. If you’re on a private well, a water test shows where your home falls.
Over time, those minerals settle in a tank as sediment. A yearly flush helps a new heater last. Our Carefree Plan covers the annual flush for $49 a year ($99 for tankless), with priority scheduling and 10% off qualifying repairs, up to $100 per visit.
Before your install
Know your heater: gas or electric, the gallons on the label, and whether a fan sits on top (power vent). A photo of the label helps.
Leaking now? Close the cold-water valve above the heater and turn off its power or gas, then call or text 317-922-9043.
Thinking tankless? See tankless water heaters in Cicero.
Cicero Water Heater Replacement FAQs
Should I repair or replace my water heater in Cicero?
If water is coming from the tank itself, or an older heater needs a major part, replacement usually makes more sense. If the tank is sound and a single part has failed, we may recommend a repair. Either way, you’ll see both options and upfront prices first.
How much does water heater replacement cost in Cicero?
We charge one flat installed price that covers the new water heater, labor, and removal of your old unit, with no added tax or fees. Current prices for each type are in the pricing section above.
How long does water heater replacement take in Cicero?
A standard tank replacement in Cicero is usually finished in one visit. Tankless conversions, or installs that need gas, venting, or electrical changes, can take longer.
Do you install water heaters for homes on private wells in Cicero?
Yes. We install gas, electric, power-vent, and tankless water heaters across Cicero, around Morse Reservoir, and in northern Hamilton County. If you’re on a private well, we’ll ask about your water and any treatment equipment before recommending a model.
Does a new water heater installed in Cicero come with a warranty?
Yes. Qualifying new tank water heaters we install come with a 6-year manufacturer warranty, and the tankless water heaters we install carry a 15-year manufacturer’s limited warranty.
Do you offer financing for water heater replacement in Cicero?
Yes. Financing is available for qualified customers, and the pricing section above shows estimated monthly payments for each water heater type.
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
What Our Customers Say
“They are extremely professional experts who show up same / next day and provide top quality services.”
Jen W.
“Hot Water Pros did exceptional work for me; they will be my go-to for all future plumbing needs.”
Andrew S.
“They came out and replaced my hot water heater today, the same day that I called them to see if they could help me!”
Laura B.
SERVICE AREAS
Proudly Serving Indianapolis and Surrounding Areas
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement
Water Heater Replacement